For most of a decade the Saturday before the Puerto Rican Day Parade belonged to Miguel Cotto and Madison Square Garden. Félix Trinidad had opened the door. A note on how a promoter's calendar trick became a homecoming.

The parade goes up Fifth Avenue on a Sunday in June. For most of a decade the night before it had a fixed address, Madison Square Garden, and a fixed headliner, a fighter from Caguas named Miguel Cotto.

The arrangement was not an accident. It was a promoter's idea, and the promoter said so.

Tito first

Before Cotto there was Félix "Tito" Trinidad, and Trinidad made the Garden feel like a Puerto Rican room before anyone put it on a calendar. On May 12, 2001, he stopped William Joppy in the fifth round there to win the WBA middleweight title, part of Don King's tournament to crown an undisputed champion. The final, against Bernard Hopkins, was set for the Garden on September 15, 2001.

Four days before it, the towers fell. The fight was postponed two weeks, to September 29, after the city and the Garden gave King their assurances. Hopkins outboxed Trinidad and stopped him in the twelfth round. Trinidad retired, came back, and fought Ricardo Mayorga at the Garden on October 2, 2004, and Roy Jones Jr. there on January 19, 2008. None of those nights was parade weekend. All of them told promoters something about who would buy tickets in New York.

Arum's calendar

Bob Arum of Top Rank had Cotto, a young champion from Caguas who was being talked about, in the island press, as the man who would carry the torch Trinidad had held. Arum had already built Mexican boxing nights around Cinco de Mayo and Mexican Independence Day in Las Vegas. He looked at New York in June.

On June 11, 2005, the night before the parade, Cotto fought Muhammad Abdullaev of Uzbekistan at the Garden. Abdullaev was an Olympic gold medalist and the last man to beat Cotto as an amateur, in the first round at the Sydney Games in 2000. The crowd cheered Cotto before the opening bell. By the ninth round Abdullaev's eye was nearly shut, and after the ringside doctor looked at it he told the referee he could not go on.

The next June, on June 10, 2006, Cotto beat the undefeated Paulie Malignaggi of Bensonhurst on a decision after cutting him in the first round. On June 9, 2007, in front of a sellout crowd, he stopped Zab Judah of Brooklyn in the eleventh. Cotto later called the Judah fight the most memorable of his parade nights, the one that showed where he was headed.

Puerto Rican Day Parade on Fifth Avenue, 2024

Photo: Deans Charbal / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0.

Cotto country

By 2009 the Associated Press was calling the Garden "Cotto Country." That week, in a corner of the South Bronx, Cotto worked out in an outdoor ring in front of hundreds of people. Women shouted. Men yelled "pound for pound." A 23-year-old named Jose Centeno, whose father was from Puerto Rico, told a reporter Cotto was "our pride." A man from Spanish Harlem, near the restaurant La Fonda Boricua where Cotto liked to eat, said Puerto Rico was a small country but it had champions.

New York at the time had close to 800,000 residents with Puerto Rican roots. The Clottey fight that Saturday, June 13, 2009, drew 17,734. It was a hard night. A clash of heads opened a bad cut over Cotto's left eye in the third round, and he won a split decision that Clottey's camp did not accept.

In June 2010 the date moved to Yankee Stadium, where Cotto fought Yuri Foreman. In 2014, on June 7, he came back to the Garden and knocked Sergio Martinez down three times in the first round, before 21,090 people, on his way to the middleweight championship.

Counting Abdullaev, Malignaggi, Judah, Clottey and Martinez, Cotto fought on the eve of the parade five times between 2005 and 2014. He fought his last fight at the Garden too, on December 2, 2017, against Sadam Ali. He told the crowd he was glad to call the place his home.

After

The cards paused during the pandemic. Top Rank brought the tradition back with an all-Puerto Rican lineup at the Garden's smaller theater, a sign that the date had outlived the fighter who made it.

"I think there will be no date in the world more important for Puerto Rican boxing than that one."

Miguel Cotto, on the parade-eve cards, to Primera Hora (San Juan). Original: "creo que no habrá fecha en el mundo más importante para el boxeo puertorriqueño que esa."

The Record is the editorial desk of Kings County. Drafted from fight records and contemporary reporting. Corrections and additions: write to the editors.

Sources